Germans will not respect MAC Directive deadline of 2011, says DUH
R744.com - 2009-04-09
Rate:
Results:
[ - ] Text [ + ]
The German car industry has stopped all developments on new refrigerants, planning to simply not comply with a EU law banning the current fluid R134a from 2011 on, according to the German NGO Deutsche Umwelthilfe. Germany’s leading TV channel ARD will focus on this issue today.
German carmakers have stopped all development plans for next-generation refrigerant currently discussed worldwide to replace R134a. Instead, they plan to still use the high global warming fluid R134a several years after the 2011 deadline set down in a EU Directive banning all refrigerants with a Global Warming Potential (GWP) of above 150. This boycott of EU legislation would not only prolong the use of climate-damaging refrigerants for up to six years, but would also keep the German automotive industry from gaining technological leadership urgently needed in the current economic crisis it faces. These are the main messages emerging from a new press release issued by the German NGO Deutsche Umwelthilfe – an active advocate of sustainable refrigerants in Mobile Air Conditioning (MAC).

Although Matthias Wissmann, President of Germany’s automotive association VDA, issued a clear commitment to the natural refrigerant CO2 already in September 2007, and reconfirmed Germany’s choice some months later, now all efforts to move towards serial production seem to have stopped. As a result, the car industry intends to undermine the EU law stipulating that from 2011 on no new car will get type approval when using R134a. With the clock ticking until this first deadline, and the Germans clearly having eliminated the competing chemical HFO-1234yf as “no option”, the only conclusion to be drawn would be a deliberate boycott by the industry, DUH states:

“If 1234yf is reportedly rejected by a majority of companies and at the same time no contract is being signed for CO2 systems, I wonder with which refrigerant the automobile industry intends to comply with the EU rules,” says Eva Lauer, DUH Project Leader for MAC.

Germans to miss out on huge economic opportunity

“If, due to economic difficulties, the boards of the car companies are stuck in a state of shock it is up to the VDA President to remind them to hold on to the already developed strategies towards a greening of the auto industry and resulting market opportunities”, the press release goes on. CO2 Technology, developed in Germany, would secure employment and a technological leadership. Wissmann, announcing in 2007 that the industry would move to the global forefront of climate protection in this “ecologically important field” should now walk the talk, prevent a breach of word and actively approach a timely compliance with the EU law through early investments in sustainable alternatives.

German TV to unveil industry’s boycott

To further draw attention to the fact that previously announced efforts for climate protection are in danger to be abandoned through a decisive non-compliance of carmakers with legislation, the political TV programme “Kontraste”, aired on Germany’s leading TV channel ARD, has prepared a report on “How the air conditioning kills the climate – automakers block climate protection.” The programme will be broadcast today, Thursday, 9.45 pm CET. R744.com will keep you updated on further developments over the next days.
More Information
Related Keywords
   MAC    EU    R-134a    HFO-1234yf    GHG emissions
 
Comments
 
First Name
Last Name
Email
(If you wish to receive notifications of new comments, please enter your email)
Anonymous
(If you check this box, your name and email will be hidden)
Post a comment: (Please do not add any links)
2009-04-14 03:26:21 - Anonymous
Tbc,
thanks for your reaction. My reaction was-- it was too good to be true with CO2 --.but -- Chemicalia is much cleverer than we think and right so, they have billions of dollars to loose in this game and will do anything possible to avoid CO2 to become the preferred refrigerant fluid in European Mac systems. The whole aftermarket in MAC service is totally against CO2 as far as new investments is concerned. Although R1234yf may be 10 xs more expensive as R134a and be just as bad for it’s toxicity of TFA & HF important is that it also complies with the new EU Regulation of a maximum Global Warming Potential of 130 figure. Extremely important for the manufacturing industry is that old R134a systems can be easily adopted to R1234yf at extreme profits for the aftermarket industry. Third world can change over without any problem and here comes the beauty of it all. You can also retrofit to HC’s without any problem Australia and USA have given us the examples, so far we have approx 4.5 million MAC systems running with HC’s and never have lost a tort case so far. (see Dr I.L.Maclaine-cross paper on hydrocarbon21.com with the title-- Usage & Risk of Hydrocarbon Refrigerant in motorcars for Australia & the United States). This is a peer reviewed paper Published by the IIR France. The HC solution is extremely important ( environmentally) for the third world and will also be important for the first world aftermarket ( be it with extreme difficulties ) both R1234yf and HC are flammable but 4.5 million MAC systems with HC’s and millions of user years in the field have proven that HC’s is exactly the answer to the MAC system pollution problems. I regret all the work done on CO2 systems but if the manufacturing industry is starting to quarrel over –Only New Models need the new fluids—than the EU made a mistake in the Regulation and the Auto/Car Industry is looking for a way out.
I would like to hear other comments on this issue from Fellow Members. It’s important to discuss these issues.
jgoz
2009-04-11 04:17:13 - Anonymous
Too bad too sad. I had planned to buy German instead of Amerirican because of the Dorchland's auto makers forward thinking. I suppose I'll be looking accross the other pond for my next truck.
2009-04-10 12:26:04 - Anonymous
Jan,

Don't get too excited just yet about 1234yf. TFA and HF issues will prove to be fatal for this chemical (even if the chemical guys are doing their best to have people not think about them).

I believe that you may have missed the point of the article above. OEMs are stopping work on all next generation refrigerants and are deliberately going against the 2011 MAC directive. They are hoping that the European Commission will do nothing. That way that can keep using 134a and the discussions, meetings and development work we've had for the last 10/15 years will have been of no use.

Regarding 1234yf, ask yourself, why is that the only guys advocating for 1234yf (besides the chemical companies themselves) are a consultant and an increasingly lonely EPA official. I challenge you to find a Press Release from an OEM in favor of 1234yf.

TBC
2009-04-10 07:27:15 - jan goedhart
it was too good to be true with CO2, probably now 1234yf as an interim !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
jgoz
© 2008 R744.com - Managed by shecco®
myR744
Username:
Password:
Remember me